Lift Replacement Projects Analysis

Lift replacement in railway stations requires precise coordination of demolition, structural modifications, and new installation while maintaining station operations. Production rates vary based on lift configuration, station complexity, and access constraints. Modern installation techniques and pre-manufactured lift systems have improved delivery timeframes, with some projects achieving complete replacements in 12-14 weeks under optimal conditions.

Key Statistics:

  • Average replacement duration: 16-20 weeks
  • Demolition phase: 2-3 weeks
  • Installation phase: 8-10 weeks
  • Testing period: 2-3 weeks
  • Typical lift height: 4-12m
  • Best practice completion: 12 weeks
  • Average cost: $800K-1.2M per lift
  • Operational reliability target: 99.5%

AUSTRALIA REGION

Location Station Scope Height (m) Type Duration (weeks) Start-End Production Rate Contractor Cost ($M) Source
Sydney Central 2 Lifts 8.5 Schindler 18 Mar21-Jul21 9 weeks/lift Liftronic 2.1 TfNSW
Melbourne Flinders 3 Lifts 10.2 KONE 24 Jun20-Dec20 8 weeks/lift Otis 3.4 MTM
Brisbane Roma St 2 Lifts 6.8 Otis 16 Sep21-Jan22 8 weeks/lift Schindler 1.8 QR
Sydney Strathfield 2 Lifts 7.5 ThyssenKrupp 20 Apr21-Sep21 10 weeks/lift KONE 2.2 Sydney Trains
Perth Perth Stn 2 Lifts 9.0 KONE 18 Jul21-Nov21 9 weeks/lift Liftronic 2.0 PTA

 

NTERNATIONAL LIFT REPLACEMENT EXAMPLES

UK REGION

Location Station Scope Height (m) Type Duration (weeks) Start-End Production Rate Contractor Cost ($M) Source
London Victoria 4 Lifts 12.5 Otis Gen3 28 Mar21-Sep21 7 weeks/lift Otis UK 3.8 Network Rail
Manchester Piccadilly 3 Lifts 9.8 KONE MonoSpace 21 Jun20-Nov20 7 weeks/lift KONE 2.9 TfGM
Birmingham New Street 5 Lifts 15.2 Schindler 5500 32 Apr21-Dec21 6.5 weeks/lift Schindler 4.5 Network Rail

EUROPEAN REGION

Location Station Scope Height (m) Type Duration (weeks) Start-End Production Rate Contractor Cost ($M) Source
Paris Gare du Nord 6 Lifts 14.0 Thyssen Evolution 36 May21-Jan22 6 weeks/lift ThyssenKrupp 5.2 SNCF
Berlin Hauptbahnhof 4 Lifts 16.5 KONE TranSys 24 Jul20-Jan21 6 weeks/lift KONE 3.9 DB
Amsterdam Centraal 3 Lifts 11.2 Schindler 7000 18 Sep21-Jan22 6 weeks/lift Schindler 2.8 NS

ASIAN REGION

Location Station Scope Height (m) Type Duration (weeks) Start-End Production Rate Contractor Cost ($M) Source
Hong Kong Central 5 Lifts 18.5 Mitsubishi NexWay 30 Feb21-Sep21 6 weeks/lift Mitsubishi 4.8 MTR
Singapore Orchard 4 Lifts 13.2 Fujitec GLVF 24 Aug20-Feb21 6 weeks/lift Fujitec 3.6 LTA
Tokyo Shinjuku 6 Lifts 15.8 Hitachi GP 32 Mar21-Nov21 5.5 weeks/lift Hitachi 5.5 JR East

Regional Performance Analysis:

Europe:

  • Average duration: 6-7 weeks/lift
  • Higher automation levels
  • Stricter safety standards
  • Better access management

Asia:

  • Average duration: 5.5-6.5 weeks/lift
  • Advanced technology integration
  • 24/7 work patterns
  • Higher passenger volumes

UK:

  • Average duration: 6.5-7.5 weeks/lift
  • Heritage considerations
  • Complex stakeholder management
  • Strict possession requirements

Technology Variations:

Modern Systems:

  1. Machine Room-Less:
  • Installation: 5-6 weeks
  • Testing: 1-2 weeks
  • Commissioning: 1 week
  1. Traditional Systems:
  • Installation: 7-8 weeks
  • Testing: 2 weeks
  • Commissioning: 1-2 weeks

Smart Features:

  • Destination control
  • Predictive maintenance
  • Energy regeneration
  • Remote monitoring

Regional Compliance Requirements:

European Union:

  • EN 81-20/50 standards
  • Energy efficiency requirements
  • Accessibility compliance
  • Safety documentation

Asia Pacific:

  • Local building codes
  • Seismic requirements
  • High-rise specifications
  • Humidity protection

UK Standards:

  • BS EN 81 series
  • Network Rail standards
  • DDA requirements
  • Fire regulations

Cost Analysis by Region:

Europe:

  • Base cost: €600K-800K/lift
  • Labor: 35-40%
  • Materials: 45-50%
  • Overheads: 15-20%

Asia:

  • Base cost: $700K-900K/lift
  • Labor: 30-35%
  • Materials: 50-55%
  • Overheads: 15%

UK:

  • Base cost: ÂŁ500K-700K/lift
  • Labor: 40-45%
  • Materials: 40-45%
  • Overheads: 15-20%

Note: All costs are indicative and subject to:

  • Exchange rates
  • Local market conditions
  • Supply chain factors
  • Regional regulations
  • Labor availability
  • Material costs

Additional Considerations:

  • Local certification requirements
  • Regional maintenance standards
  • Spare parts availability
  • Warranty conditions
  • Service life expectations
  • Energy efficiency requirements
  • Environmental regulations
  • Local labor laws

 

 

Project Phase Analysis:

Demolition Phase:

  1. Preparation (5-7 days):
  • Hoarding installation
  • Service isolation
  • Protection works
  • Access establishment
  1. Removal Works (10-14 days):
  • Car removal: 2-3 days
  • Guide rail removal: 3-4 days
  • Equipment removal: 4-5 days
  • Shaft cleaning: 2-3 days

Installation Phase:

  1. Structural Works (2-3 weeks):
  • Shaft modifications
  • Landing preparations
  • Support steel installation
  • Pit modifications
  1. Lift Installation (6-8 weeks):
  • Guide rails: 5-7 days
  • Car assembly: 8-10 days
  • Machine room equipment: 5-7 days
  • Controls installation: 7-9 days
  • Doors and frames: 5-6 days
  1. Finishing Works (2-3 weeks):
  • Landing finishes
  • Car interior
  • Signage
  • Lighting

Testing and Commissioning:

  1. Initial Testing (7-10 days):
  • Safety systems
  • Emergency features
  • Control systems
  • Door operations
  1. Certification (5-7 days):
  • Independent inspection
  • Documentation review
  • Compliance verification
  • Handover preparation

Project Milestones:

Pre-Construction:

  • Design approval: 4-6 weeks
  • Material procurement: 12-16 weeks
  • Planning approvals: 6-8 weeks
  • Stakeholder engagement: 4-6 weeks

Construction Phase:
Week 1-2: Site establishment
Week 2-4: Demolition
Week 4-12: Installation
Week 12-14: Finishing
Week 14-16: Testing
Week 16-18: Commissioning

 

Note 1: Production rates are indicative only.

Note 2: Rates vary based on:

  • Station complexity
  • Access constraints
  • Heritage requirements
  • Operational impacts
  • Interface requirements

Note 3: Duration calculation formula:
D = (BT Ă— CF Ă— AF) + TC, where:

  • D = Total duration
  • BT = Base time
  • CF = Complexity factor (1.0-1.6)
  • AF = Access factor (1.0-1.4)
  • TC = Testing constant

Influencing Factors:

  • Station operations
  • Heritage constraints
  • Service relocations
  • Weather protection
  • Material delivery
  • Working hours
  • Safety requirements
  • Passenger management
  • Testing requirements
  • Certification process

Risk Mitigation:

  1. Access Management:
  • Alternative paths
  • Temporary facilities
  • Clear signage
  • Customer assistance
  1. Safety Controls:
  • Work zone isolation
  • Dust control
  • Noise management
  • Public protection
  1. Quality Assurance:
  • Regular inspections
  • Progress monitoring
  • Documentation control
  • Compliance checking

 


Other production rates – Indicative only

Ads Blocker Image Powered by Code Help Pro

Ads Blocker Detected!!!

We have detected that you are using extensions to block ads. Please support us by disabling these ads blocker.

Powered By
100% Free SEO Tools - Tool Kits PRO